High school buds Johnny Riley and J.J. Knight catch up years later over a couple of cold ones, but things between them quickly heat up when J.J. learns that Johnny used to have a crush on him. Childhood friends Wesley Woods and Jason Styles are barely out of their first bro-hug since college when Wesley makes the moves on his bewildered buddy. Derrick Dime may not have been away long from his soulmate Lukas Grande, but even a few hours waiting feels like an eternity until they reunite for an intimate evening together. Johnny Torque can't stand that his new boyfriend won't let him fuck him bareback, so in a moment of weakness Johnny follows his ex into the bathroom and pounds him raw just like old times. And even though Brenner Bolton's never had sex before, his fantasies of longing bring on a sense of déjà vu as he's brought face to face (and ass-to-cock) with his favorite porn crush.